What is a forecast worth once it has failed? In Ep. 136 of The Grant Williams Podcast, released four days after the 2026 midterms handed the House and the Senate to the Democrats, Marvin Barth of Thematic Markets returns to take apart the call he made in Ep. 135, which had the Republicans holding on. His verdict is that the framework held and the conclusion did not: the low-trust voters he was looking for were real and the polls missed them, but they voted against the Republicans , an error he traces to his own biases . The rest of the hour follows the result forward, into fiscal policy, the Fed, markets and the Iran war, without which, Barth says, this would be “absolutely a different world” .
Key Topics
- Barth lists the four assumptions behind his call and says the polling errors were “bigger this year than they were in 2024 or 2016” but this time overstated the Republicans, by four to five points , in what “may turn out to be the most participated in midterm election in a century” .
- He reads the result as a punishment of the Republicans, not an endorsement of the Democrats, since most state ballot initiatives went the Republican way , and calls an electorate this mobile “a great sign for a democracy” .
- Citing 2010, when the Democrats were routed after Obamacare passed and Barack Obama won comfortably two years later , Barth warns against reading the result through to 2028, and welcomes Hakeem Jeffries’ line that investigations are “not our focus” .
- Grant thinks the Democrats have the harder road ; Barth, warning that he will sound partisan, argues that their internal debate and deeper bench leave the Republicans “in a much better position for 2028” .
- On policy, Barth says “we can forget about fiscal consolidation” (cutting the deficit) : a tax deal is possible, but in his reading of OECD evidence “the only policy that works” for a highly indebted economy is cutting spending .
- He expects Kevin Warsh, freed from what he calls “the lamest of lame ducks in history” , to act as a hawk and push up real interest rates (rates after inflation) , and expects new curbs on AI data centers to slow investment and cap earnings growth .
- Grant measures Warsh against Paul Volcker, “the gold standard of central bankers in a crisis” , then the two disagree over Scott Bessent , whom Barth counts with Marco Rubio among the administration’s “good hands” .
- Barth says every US war since World War II has cost the party in power , expects more American isolationism , and says the result kills his “what would Jackson do” rule for reading Trump , adding that Trump no longer has the congressional support a blockade of Iran would need .
Notable Quotes
"Populism, the very base of it means the appealing to the people. Well, isn't that what a democracy is supposed to be?"Marvin Barth, The Grant Williams Podcast: Forecasts and Fortunes, Episode 2 (7 Nov 2026), 12:07
"This was punishing Republicans for straying."Marvin Barth, on the midterm result, The Grant Williams Podcast: Forecasts and Fortunes, Episode 2 (7 Nov 2026), 13:18
"But every single time the Americans say, no more foreign wars, stupid. And every single time they still do it."Marvin Barth, The Grant Williams Podcast: Forecasts and Fortunes, Episode 2 (7 Nov 2026), 47:08
Outline
- 0:00:49 — The morning after
- 0:04:08 — Four assumptions, three right
- 0:09:12 — A MAGA loss, not a Democratic win
- 0:11:10 — Populism is a good thing
- 0:15:33 — Can the Democrats keep them?
- 0:20:38 — Which party has the harder road
- 0:26:45 — Fiscal consolidation is off
- 0:30:35 — A hawk without a leash
- 0:34:01 — Warsh and the Volcker test
- 0:38:25 — Bessent and the good hands
- 0:45:20 — The war that lost the election
- 0:49:01 — The two rules, revisited
Mentioned Resources
People
- Marvin Barth (researcher behind Thematic Markets and the episode’s guest)
- Donald Trump (Republican president weakened by the midterm result)
- Kevin Warsh (Fed chair Barth expects to act as a hawk)
- Scott Bessent (Treasury Secretary over whom Grant and Barth disagree)
- Marco Rubio (Secretary of State, one of Barth’s “good hands”)
- Paul Volcker (former Fed chair whose reputation grew after office)
- Jerome Powell (former Fed chair whose reputation suffered)
- Alan Greenspan (former Fed chair revered in office, diminished since)
- Ben Bernanke (former Fed chair whose reputation was worn down by events)
- Tim Geithner (former Treasury Secretary, loud by necessity)
- Janet Yellen (former Treasury Secretary, a quiet one)
- Jack Lew (former Treasury Secretary remembered for his signature)
- Hakeem Jeffries (prospective new Speaker of the House)
- James Talarico (Texas Democrat offering to work with Trump on housing)
- Thomas Massie (Republican dissenter Trump tried to drive out of the party)
- Abdul El-Sayed (Democratic Senate nominee in Michigan)
- Mike Rogers (Republican Senate candidate in Michigan)
- Michael Green (earlier podcast guest on the Treasury buyback program)
- Barack Obama (former president whose 2010 rout is Barth’s precedent)
- Joe Biden (former president under whom the buyback program began)
- Kamala Harris (2024 Democratic nominee)
- Hillary Clinton (2016 Democratic nominee)
- J.D. Vance (vice president whose verdict on the war Trump echoed)
- George W. Bush (president who first brought Warsh to the Fed)
- Harry Truman (president during the Korean War)
- Pete Hegseth (Trump cabinet pick Barth calls disruptive)
- Matt Gaetz (Trump pick Barth calls disruptive)
- Ted Kennedy (the late senator whose Massachusetts seat a Republican won in 2010)
- Andrew Jackson (namesake of Barth’s rule for reading Trump)
Organizations
- Thematic Markets (Marvin Barth’s research firm)
- Republican Party (the party voters punished, in Barth’s reading)
- Democratic Party (winner of both chambers)
- MAGA Movement (Donald Trump’s political movement)
- Federal Reserve (the US central bank)
- US Senate (the upper chamber of Congress)
- House of Representatives (the lower chamber of Congress)
Places
- Kansas (state that sent a Democrat to the Senate for the first time in 100 years)
- Mississippi (state whose Democratic wins drew attention)
- Massachusetts (state that elected a Republican to the Senate in 2010)
- Michigan (state whose Democratic Senate primary Barth cites)
- China (the US rival in the AI build-out)
- United Kingdom (one of the countries already raising rates)
Works
- The Grant Williams Podcast (Grant Williams’ interview show)
- Obamacare (the Affordable Care Act)
Concepts
- Low-Trust Voters (populist voters who skip polls but turn out)
- Polling Bias (polling error that runs in one direction)
- Populism (in Barth’s definition, political disenfranchisement)
- Mobile Voters (the swing electorate attached to no party)
- Ballot Initiatives (state referenda decided by voters directly)
- Fiscal Consolidation (cutting a deficit through spending cuts and tax rises)
- Real Interest Rates (interest rates adjusted for inflation)
- AI Investment (spending on artificial intelligence and data centers)
- Treasury Buyback Program (the Treasury’s repurchases of its own debt)
- Tariffs (taxes on imports)
- Isolationism (a withdrawal from foreign entanglements)
- Lame Duck (a final-term president losing power)
- What Would Jackson Do (Barth’s rule of thumb for predicting Trump)
- Jacksonian Populism (the tradition descended from Andrew Jackson)
- Immigration (part of the MAGA policy set)
Events
- 2026 US Midterm Elections (the vote the forecast got wrong)
- 2010 US Midterm Elections (Barth’s precedent for a midterm rout)
- 2024 US Presidential Election (the swing that 2026 reversed)
- 2028 US Presidential Election (the next presidential race)
- Iran War (the US conflict with Iran)
- Korean War (the first war in Barth’s list)
Closing
Paired with the forecast that preceded it, the episode shows a call being audited in public, separating what the framework got right from the one assumption that sank it.
← Marvin Barth: The Voters the Polls Can’t See · Frank Giustra: What Money Is For →