Marvin Barth's rule of thumb for predicting Donald Trump: when Trump's course is unclear, ask what Andrew Jackson would have done. In episode 01 he uses it to forecast both the end of the Iran war and a turn to fiscal consolidation. In episode 02, after the midterms, he says the result has broken the rule. Start with episode 01, at about 55 minutes, then episode 02, at about 49 minutes.
Across the episodes
Enters as Barth's forecasting heuristic for Trump, used to reach both of his counter-consensus predictions
Barth's joke on a religious slogan carries a serious forecasting rule.
"And so one of my new rules for life is, or not rules for life, I don't apply this in my personal life, but rules for understanding Trump is WWJD. But not what would Jesus do? It's what would Jackson do?"Marvin, The Grant Williams Podcast: Forecasts and Fortunes, Episode 1 (2 Nov 2026), 55:10
The rule's scope: it is for the moments when Trump is hardest to read.
"Because whatever Jackson would do is often the right answer for what Trump will do when you're confused."Marvin, The Grant Williams Podcast: Forecasts and Fortunes, Episode 1 (2 Nov 2026), 55:28
Barth combines the rule with Trump's concern for his legacy to reach the fiscal call.
"And so this comes back to what would Jackson do? And also... his legacy."Marvin, The Grant Williams Podcast: Forecasts and Fortunes, Episode 1 (2 Nov 2026), 58:43
He returns to both rules to justify what he calls an out-there call.
"comes back to this, what would Jackson do and what is going to put him in the history books?"Marvin, The Grant Williams Podcast: Forecasts and Fortunes, Episode 1 (2 Nov 2026), 1:06:26
Is retired by its author: Barth says the rule worked through the coalition around Trump, and with that coalition scattering it no longer predicts him
Barth brings both of his episode-01 rules back to be tested against the result.
"One is that we talked about last time, these two rules I have for how to forecast Donald Trump."Marvin, The Grant Williams Podcast: Forecasts and Fortunes, Episode 2 (7 Nov 2026), 49:03
The rule's hidden mechanism, revealed in its failure: it predicted Trump partly by predicting the people around him.
"This week's result kills the first one in the following sense, in that what would Jackson do was a good predictor of him in part because his instincts seem to be very Jacksonian,"Marvin, The Grant Williams Podcast: Forecasts and Fortunes, Episode 2 (7 Nov 2026), 49:24
The verdict: the heuristic is withdrawn.
"So the Jacksonian stuff is out the window now."Marvin, The Grant Williams Podcast: Forecasts and Fortunes, Episode 2 (7 Nov 2026), 50:08
Connections
The rule's model.
Barth applies it to the budget.
Barth withdraws the rule after the vote.