Point at a sentence to see when it was said, and click the time to listen from there.Tap a sentence to see when it was said, and tap the time to listen from there.

Grant Williams

Before we get going, here's the bit where I remind you that nothing we discuss should be considered as investment advice. This conversation is for informational and hopefully entertainment purposes only. So while we hope you find it both informative and entertaining, please do your own research or speak to a financial advisor before putting a dime of your money into these crazy markets. And now... on with the show. Welcome everybody to another edition of the Grant Williams podcast. They're like buses.

The morning after

Grant Williams

You wait for about three weeks when there isn't one and people just start to contact me and say when's the next one coming and now you're drowning in the bloody things. Well this one is all about the morning after the night before. I had my friend Marvin Barth on last week who made a left field prediction about the elections on Tuesday night and Certainly the result did come out of left field, I guess is the way to put that. But Marvin very graciously contacted me and said, look, obviously I got this catastrophically wrong, but I want to talk about why and talk about the reasons the elections went the way they did. I think there's a lot of information in that. And I was delighted to have this chance to talk to him about that, to have a post-mortem of his predictions and to hear him run through the reasons for what he got wrong, why he was... surprised and what that means going forward and this conversation is absolutely fantastic now i put the original podcast out in its entirety and i'll do the same with this one because that's only fair and anytime the podcast goes out beyond the paywall and people listen to it in isolation i expect to find a lot of people coming on that wouldn't normally comment on the podcast and the nature of those comments was also fairly predictable most of it to berate marvin which i find very sad but not sadly completely unpredictable. Hopefully people can listen to this and recognize that it's not about the outcome.

It's about the thought process that goes into it. And I, for one, going into an event like Tuesday, where everybody was so certain of the outcome, the one thing I was looking for was a reasoned, rational explanation as to how it could go the other way. And Marvin certainly gave me that. It didn't work out that way, but I genuinely don't care. I was interested in the quality of his process, which is second to none. And I'm even more interested to hear him reflect upon what went wrong and talk about it. And you are about to get the chance to do that. So without any further ado, here is my conversation with Marvin Barth.

Marvin, my friend, you must have had a quiet couple of days.

Marvin Barth

Yeah, it's been pretty sleepy around here. But I must be doing something right because this is three weeks in a row now I've gotten to be with you. We went out to dinner. I come on your podcast last week and now I'm on your podcast again. Here we go. I mean, goodness gracious, how could I get any more lucky?

Grant Williams

Well, listen, I'm delighted to have you. And I just thought this was a great chance for us to talk about Tuesday because last week I had a great conversation and you laid out a really well thought out case as to why the election could go the other way. And obviously they didn't. And you were the first to own that on Twitter. I loved your tweet on Twitter. But the point of this podcast, the thing that I'm trying to do and the thing that over the years, it seems most of my listeners want is just thoughtful perspectives. And so for me, if there's any event that everybody is absolutely convinced is going to go hard one way, I want to hear someone thoughtfully make a case for the other side. And even if they're wrong, I want to understand, okay, how could it go the other way? And I thought you did that really well. And it didn't come to pass, but predicting the future is a tricky enterprise. So let's talk about, because you were keen to come back and talk about this, which I love. So let's talk about the post-mortem first, because you've obviously been awake, looking through all the numbers. Let's do the post-mortem first, and then we'll get into what this might mean going forward.

Four assumptions, three right

Marvin Barth

Let's start with where I came from. What were the things that were driving my view? And I had effectively based that on four it. things. One, that there is a set of low trust voters that exists out there who do not respond to polls. That's part of being low trust, but they do vote in sufficient numbers to swing an election and that two, they come out to vote when there's populism or at least something that appeals to them on the ballot. And then, of course, third was that my view was there was something on the ballot that this was a populist referendum and that. those same group of unresponsive populists would ultimately vote for Republicans because Donald Trump has taken that mantle of the disaffected voter and the issues that they felt were not being heard by both the traditional Republicans and the traditional Democrats.

And when you, the problem with... polls is that because these people don't show up, because they don't answer the phone, because they don't go on online polls, is that if they're coming out to vote in one particular direction, you're going to get a polling bias. And I went through all the parts of that in my original piece explaining how I was searching for people who weren't in the polls. Now, the interesting thing is, of course, there were actually really big polling errors. This is, I think, the biggest takeaway here is that the polling errors were bigger this year than they were in 2024 or 2016. They were on the order of what we saw in 2020. And the difference was, is that rather than erring towards overstating Democrats, it overstated Republicans. So you had somewhere between a four and five percentage point swing in the actual vote relative to the polls in favor of Democrats.

And you say, okay, well, maybe that's just a polling error, not bias in the polls. And how is this related to the people who I was looking for before? And if you look through demographic by demographic. What you find is that the swings were nearly identical and in the opposite direction to the swings to Trump in 2024 by demographic. That those were particularly associated with groups that are underrepresented, the ones that don't show up in polls as frequently as others. And that they were most associated with the polling errors. So it's not definitive evidence that these were the same people, but then you combine that with the fact that you had, this was, we'll see at the final numbers, this may turn out to be the most participated in midterm election in a century, but it was certainly the, at least the second largest in a century. So this was not a low turnout election. You had massive turnout and you had.

All the exact same groups switch directions. And you see these interviews over the last 24 hours with people at polling stations, things like that. What were they upset about? And there were tons of these people who clearly had voted for Donald Trump, swung the other way. And then you look at the exit polls and what was the single biggest issue that seemed to be on exit polls? It was the Iran war. People were really upset. They felt betrayed. But you go down the list, it was all these things that seemed to be things that Trump's voters felt they were betrayed by. And so if I look through the sort of four things that I thought were going to drive polling errors in favor of Trump, the first three all effectively looked like they were true. It was that final assumption that they were going to vote for Republicans that was the one that was wrong. And I think that in deep introspection comes down to my own biases here. But the framework, which is really what I try and focus on, what I think is the most important thing for an analyst to look at, actually did seem to work.

A MAGA loss, not a Democratic win

Marvin Barth

I just imposed a bias on it that gave me the wrong answer.

Grant Williams

You know what I find really interesting is that when you make a wrong call, everybody wants to know why you got it wrong. But when you make a right call, nobody cares. But it's really important to understand if you were right for the right reasons or right for the wrong reasons. And you don't get any introspection on that. And so when I look at the results, as you say, you called the first three correct. There are a big cohort of low-trust voters who don't respond to polls. They do vote for populism reliably. And populism is on the ballot. Those three were inarguable. As you say, the missing part was you figured they'd go red. They went blue in their waves. But if I look at that, then... I don't see this necessarily as a massive Democrat win. And look, I'm English. I have no dog in this hunt whatsoever. So no one can accuse me of being a salty Republican or whatever the word is for my age. I just, I'm observing it. I don't see this as a massive Democrat win as I do a massive Republican or even, you want to define it, a MAGA loss.

Marvin Barth

Yes. And that implications- There's another group that lost even more, by the way. Well, come on to that in a second.

Grant Williams

I'm curious to hear that. But what that says to me looking forward is that this massive swing block that you've correctly identified will be up for grabs again in 2028. And if the Democrats go back to Harris slash Biden type policies, further left, further redistributive, et cetera, et cetera, then we could see another. So we're not out of the woods. This is not, in my view. a return to, oh my God, thanks, we're going back to small government Republicans. It feels to me as though it's more of a, we are sick of this on the right, but we're just sick of kind of everything and we want something more representative of us. Is that wildly wrong?

Populism is a good thing

Grant Williams

And if so, why?

Marvin Barth

So I don't think that's wrong. And it's, I think in many ways, one of the things that may surprise people. especially a lot of people who thought that I had these deep biases in favor of Trump or Republicans. As we mentioned in our last podcast, I was a Republican administration. And in general, my political leanings are towards the Republicans. And I actually have been very much in favor of many of the things Donald Trump has done in terms of building a moat to a re-industrialize the United States, aligning domestic and international priorities, all these things that frankly populists did vote for. There were lots of other things I wasn't happy about, but ultimately I'm an American first and foremost, and I like to see that the country wins and works. And one of the things that I've been trying to emphasize over and over to... what you might call both sides, is that populism is a good thing. Populism, the very base of it means the appealing to the people.

Well, isn't that what a democracy is supposed to be? And what I would read the election very much exactly as you did. And in fact, in my post-mortem, I go back and make the point that, first of all, in this massive blue wave, if you look at... referenda. A lot of U.S. states have these ballot initiatives on direct democracy issues. And most of those, not all of them, but most of them went very much in favor of the direction of what you would consider Republican issues. More voter ID laws, restrictions on transgender rights, caps on taxation, increased property rights, all of these sorts of things that you would have thought Gosh, this looked like a Republican wave on the ballot initiatives. And yet, if you were a person on a ballot, you got slaughtered if you were Republican on Tuesday. So one, that tells you this was not about agreement with where the Democrats were taking things. This was punishing Republicans for straying.

But two, you go back to that point I made that these were, you had 20 plus point swings in some demographics that were mirror images of what they did two years ago, right? This is telling you that you have a electorate that is highly mobile right now, that is extremely fluid and not attached to any one party. That's a great sign for a democracy. That means people are actually going to have to compete for their votes. This is fantastic news. Everybody should be jumping up and down celebrating this outcome because it really is good news. And if you go back and look even further, the same set of voters, you can go back and look through elections, is literally the exact same set of voters who voted for Barack Obama in 2008, then voted for Donald Trump in 2016. Moved away from him somewhat or back and forth in 2020, came back to him in 2024, and now they're moving away from him. And it is them telling both parties, hey. We want you to listen to us.

And what was really, I'm sorry, I'm probably jumping ahead to one of your questions, but since I wrote this, just reviewing the news today, I'm even more excited about it. If you listen to the Democratic leadership, my goodness, the Democrats themselves sound like they actually got the message, right? It wasn't just them running away saying, hey, we won, we're going to do what we want. No, they actually sound like, we understand why the Republicans got schlocked here and we're going to try and do something to help you.

Can the Democrats keep them?

Grant Williams

Is that possible in this environment? Because we're talking about this group in the middle. We're talking about, as you call them, the mobile voters who are happy to swing either way, which I agree with you is a fantastic thing. I was curious about the idea of being a registered. Republican or registered Democrat, because with that comes, it feels like an obligation to vote. That's my team. I've got to vote for my team. And I was always struck in my time in America, which you didn't have here in England. No one asks you who you vote for in England. It's just not a topic. But in America, everybody was like, oh, so you're a Republican or you're a Democrat, as if that defined you. But I'm curious as to whether it's possible on the left for the Democrats to heed this warning and do something effectively to mobilize and hold on to that big swing group, because it feels like the issues that are important to them and the things the Democrats would have to do to really keep them in 2028 are at odds with what their hardcore base seem to really want, which is all the things that those mobile voters voted against in the last selection.

Marvin Barth

I would say that's one of the reasons why I was so heartened by what I was hearing today. And you can see signs that already that there's a backlash from what you would call their hardcore voters. But in my sort of postmortem, looking forward on some of the lessons learned is that, one, these voters are highly mobile. And I specifically said you should not read through to 2028 for this. In 2010, voters did the exact same thing to Democrats, schlacking them by similar numbers of seats. Not, by the way, in the popular vote margin, by similar numbers of seats after Obamacare passed. And two years later, Barack Obama wins comfortably. Everybody's focused on Kansas and Mississippi electing Democrats. And we just point out, yeah, in 2010, Massachusetts, deep blue Massachusetts elected a Republican to Ted Kennedy's seat. Now, they kicked him out two years later, right?

Angry voters do crazy things here. And so, my thought was that the Democrats would face a problem here if they do listen to what their base was telling them because as we discussed with the referenda that didn't seem to be what voters want. But more importantly, what I thought is even more is like, I can't remember who's the incoming head of the judicial committee in the house was telling various members of the Trump administration to lawyer up on X. And that was something people really wanted. They want them to go after them and punish them criminally as they did, by the way, in the 2020 through 2024 period. And you got a lot of backlash from that. And more importantly, if you look back in history, Newt Gingrich, after successfully turning the House Republican for the first time in 30 years, made the fatal error of trying to go after, make the 1998 election all about Bill Clinton and Monica Lewinsky. And it was, as we discussed on the last episode, one of the few times in history that this... sitting president's party picked up seats.

So the Democrats really face that same thing if they go after Trump. And so that's what was really interesting to hear this morning is that Hakeem Jeffries, the prospective new Speaker of the House, said, yeah, there'll probably be investigations, but that's not our focus. We're going to try and get things done. And if you look at all the comments on posts about this, it's all these hardcore supporters. You are, you're not the right man for the job. You should step out of the race. You shouldn't be house speaker because there are a lot of people who are out there for blood. But if they want to appeal to these voters that are going to swing, they have to do something other than just attack the other side. And you heard James Talarico saying the exact same thing. He said, investigations are not going to be our focus. And in fact, I'm looking forward to working with President Trump on getting building and construction restrictions lifted so we can build homes for young people like that. is the type of thing that is going to move both parties forward if they actually do these types of things. So I do think there's room for it here, but I'm not naive enough to think that we're through the woods yet.

Which party has the harder road

Marvin Barth

I think this is going to be a long-term process shaking out on both sides in both parties.

Grant Williams

I think exactly the same thing, but as I looked at it, I couldn't help but thing that the Democrats probably have a tougher road ahead of them because But realistically speaking, on the right, what they have to do is really moderate personalities and they have to moderate, like the policies seem to be a lot of the things that people want. The policies seem to be, okay, you're going to have to tweak them. You're going to have to change a few around. Obviously, the Iran war is a big one. But a lot of the Republican policies, if they're delivered by a different. speaker, if there's a different personality delivering them to a base, I think you can get those people back. Where, as I look at the Democrats, it feels like they've got to actively change a lot of their policies, not just the communication. Again, I'm curious as to your thoughts on that, because as I say, I'm just looking at this with eyes far less sophisticated than yours and trying to figure it out.

Marvin Barth

That self-deprecation is unwarranted. But I'm going to say, now I am going to sound like a partisan and probably. piss off some of your, not just Democrat, but left of center listeners out there, which is, and I will go back and cite specific evidence around this. So in the 2016 election, I can't remember whether it was the independent or the guardian here in the UK, did this fantastic social experiment where they got left-wing and right-wing or Republican and Democratic supporters to swap Twitter feeds, back in those days when it used to be called Twitter, and then report back to them on what they found. And both sides reported, oh, my God, those people on the other side are absolutely nuts. I can't stand them. They're horrible. They're awful, terrible people. They should probably all die. Both sides were very unfriendly about the other side. There was one big difference between the two sides, however.

Thank you. Democrats, who had gotten Republican feeds, all expressed amazing shock at how much debate there was on the Republican side and how free Republicans felt to challenge each other on ideas and have an exchange of different ideas that they said just does not take place on their side at all. And the Republicans corroborated that. They said, we're shocked at the uniformity of thought. in Democratic feeds. Like nobody questions anything. And if you do, you immediately get attacked. And that's not an isolated instance. If you look through time, just look at what happened to, I can't remember the woman in Michigan who had run against El-Sayed for the Democratic nomination for Senate. And she came out and endorsed Mike Rogers, the Republican, two days before the election. And yeah, I can see why a lot of Democrats would be upset about, but the vitriol that was aimed at her for violating this was extreme. And you see this over and over again.

The left does not tolerate dissent. And I think that's the real problem. And that really goes back to your previous question. Are the Democrats actually going to be able to move away from their hardcore? believers. I think that's the biggest problem is that uniformity of thought, that inability to even express different ideas is going to constrain them. Whereas on the Republican side, look, you've got people that President Trump just tried to kick out of the party, including Thomas Massie, all these guys who are going to come out with all different ideas. You're going to get an exchange of different ideas and voters in the primary process are going to pick the ones they like the best and they're going to have better quality candidates coming forward because of that. The other point that I make is that both President Trump and President Obama presided over decimation of their parties at lower levels of government. The difference was Barack Obama did that early in his administration. So by the time he left after eight years, there was nobody coming up through the ranks who was a potential significant.

You had just had all these old people who'd been around for decades. And this is how we ended up getting Hillary Clinton, how we got. Joe Biden and Kamala Harris. There just wasn't a strong bench behind them, behind him. Donald Trump, fortunately for the Republicans, didn't do this until the very end of his second term, after a time when you raised a whole crop of significant challengers with, as I said, very diverse ideological views. So I actually think the Republicans are in a much better position for 2028. than the Democrats, just on the basis of those two points.

Grant Williams

It's so interesting because already I can feel the fingernails sharpening as people head for the keyboards. We call you a Republican lackey and we know how this goes. But again, I look at this and if I'm trying to be optimistic about it, the way I see this going is right, the Democrats genuinely do learn their lessons and move much more centrists, much further away from the extreme left of the party And that would be fantastic because to defeat them, the Republicans are going to have to do the same. They're going to have to move towards the middle because of this big block, which is unilaterally fantastic and unequivocally good for America that the debate suddenly becomes about ideas in the middle as opposed to ideas in the fringe. Because you can't debate those. You can only argue them. You can't debate the extremes.

Fiscal consolidation is off

Grant Williams

You can debate the middle, but the rest is so difficult. So with that being said... As you look forward to what happens now with the Democrats holding the House and the Senate, Trump essentially a lame duck, but with the power of veto, which we already know he loves to use, let's talk about the policy implications for the next couple of years. You wrote about it in your postmortem. So let's walk through how you see policy changing now going forward from here.

Marvin Barth

The first is we can forget about fiscal consolidation. So in the last episode I was on about whether anybody could bring about fiscal consolidation. And I made the also out of consensus case, and maybe I was just as wrong about that, but we'll never know, that really the only party that was arguing for fiscal consolidation, forget about what you hear from the politicians themselves. Look at what the voters are telling you in poll after poll. is that 70, 80% of Republican voters are telling you they want the deficit under control and want to cut federal spending. You look at Democrats, it's barely an issue, like very few. If you're lucky, if you get 20% care. And so obviously the only side that has their voters telling them do something about this is the Republican. So that's why I thought. that you actually were likely to get something if you got Republican House, Senate, and a president looking to burnish his credentials in history.

I don't see that possible right now, but I do see, I will say, and again, I'm seeing the Democratic response today makes me even more hopeful that actually maybe I'm underestimating the likelihood of this, that you do get actually some revenue side measures. Because if you recall, what I anticipated was that on the revenue side, President Trump would want to raise taxes on the richest people, the very populist maneuver, to offset tariffs that are falling hardest on middle class households. You can obviously see the Democrats would go along with the first part of that.

And there is a significant number of Democrats who are. moving towards the whole tariff part. So if they're actually willing to cross the aisle and work with President Trump as they're claiming this morning, then actually there's room for a deal there that raises taxes. The problem is that if you look at the econometric evidence across the whole range of OECD countries, 24 some odd OECD countries going back three or four decades in the data. If you look at what's happened with highly indebted economies, the only policy that works to put you back on track to fiscal sustainability is cutting spending. It's the only one, literally the only one.

Revenue-based fiscal consolidations never work. Not one has ever worked. And so that means that if you just do it from the revenue side, you're not going to get there. And I don't see the Democrats with their base and with their priorities being able to cut spending significantly. So I think fiscal sustainability is definitely delayed for not just two years, but because the Democrats actually... won a significant number of Senate seats.

A hawk without a leash

Marvin Barth

We're talking at least into the early part of the 2030s. So that's got to be bad for bond markets there. There's another bad thing for bond markets here, which is the Federal Reserve, right? So I have maintained all along that Kevin Warsh is a hawk. His whole career is being a hawk. And I know lots of people didn't want to believe it because Donald Trump... would never appoint a hawk, whatever. Well, he did. The guy has hiked rates, not enough. I've been very disappointed so far in how hawkish he's been, but I thought that was largely him trying to pull the rest of the committee on side early on. And then I do think that he probably took a pass last week to avoid angering the orange haired man. Well, guess what? Donald Trump is now the lamest of lame ducks in history. So now... You're a relatively young guy who's rich, who has everything else. Why would you give a damn what Donald Trump writes on Twitter when it's your legacy on the line here? That guy's going to be a hawk. He's going to be fully open to be a hawk. And you know what? He might actually get more cooperation from the rest of the committee because all of them now too are going to feel like, oh, we don't have to try and thwart Donald Trump.

We can work with this guy because he's ready to fight against Donald Trump and the guy who's been trying to investigate all of us criminally. So you put those two things together, I think there's a very clear implication for interest rates here that real interest rates have to rise significantly. That's been one of my firm positions I've had for a long time. This opens the door to that. So that's an important policy set. We also have that you're going to get, and you can see it in markets today, more restrictions on artificial intelligence and on data centers being built. That was another clear thing from ballot initiatives across the United States. And this has been a big democratic position.

And so that's going to put pressure on a lot of that CapEx spending and AI data centers and the arms race between the U.S. and China. Now, how that's going to play out in markets, I would say the interesting question is, does that actually bring about a credit event or does it actually delay and potentially forestall one? Because you take off the pressure of the big boom and everybody rushing out to issue more debt. Maybe that actually slows it down and people can grow into their existing debt profiles. I think that has a lot to do with. how quickly Chinese development perhaps undermines the profit margins of the people who've already issued the debt. I don't think we know the answer to that, but what we do know is that it is going to slow earnings growth and definitely cap earnings growth in the future. And so that's an important input into equity markets, which when you have rising real rates, a steepening yield curve, all of those things are not going to play well for equities. Doesn't mean we're going to get a crash, but it does suggest that equities are not going to give us the type of returns that they were expected to before.

Grant Williams

The oxygen is getting thinner up here.

Warsh and the Volcker test

Grant Williams

But let's go back to Kevin Warsh for a second. So I think this is really interesting. Now, I don't know Kevin Warsh. I haven't met Kevin Warsh. I know plenty of people who have and who do. And the thread that runs through what I've been told by people who do know him is that he is someone who, how do I put this? diplomatically. He won't be unconcerned with his legacy, is how he's been described to me. This is someone who is not going to think, well, it doesn't matter what people think of me in the future, I'm just going to do whatever I need to do. So I have to think that any central banker worth his salt, there's only one central banker in modern history whose legacy has been burnished over time, and that is Paul Volcker, right? He's the only one. Greenspan was an absolute sage until he left office. And then slowly but surely, his reputation has been torn down by events. Bernanke's the same. Powell had it done to him while he was in office by Trump.

Volcker's the only guy who, if you're playing along,

Marvin Barth

I would say Powell did that to himself. Yeah,

Grant Williams

that's fair enough. That's fair enough. But Volcker's the only one who 40 years after his time in office, as much as he was maligned by certain parts of society then, he's now the gold standard of central bankers in a crisis. So what you've told me there about Warsh, what I understand about his nature, it strikes me as the path of least resistance from a China figure. out is that, is exactly what you say, hawkishness is likely to be. He's got the cover for it. The fact that the UK raised rates, there are other countries raising rates, which gives him more cover for it. And being the tough guy in 25, 30 years is going to feel pretty good. As you say, he's a young man in 25 to 30 years, he'll be able to remember this stuff, whereas a lot of people won't.

Marvin Barth

The only way, forget about 20, 25 years. The only way he gets reappointed as Fed chair in four years is if he's brought inflation under control. That was one of the key issues in the election. People were telling you, we're angry about the cost of living. That's different from inflation, but a lot of people conflate the two. And in general, an older population in the United States is not going to be happy about inflation. So every signal is telling you the best thing this guy can do. is err on the side of fighting inflation. And I don't know him either. I have met him once. He impressed me as quite intelligent, but I've definitely seen signs of exactly what you diplomatically described him as. And the other thing I've heard from every single person who worked with him, remember he came into the Fed. in his mid-30s. And he was seen as a political lackey of George Bush at the time. So the internal attitude of the other FOMC members at the time and of the Fed staff, and I knew people in both, was some political lackey that we have to deal with, that the president is stuck in here.

And literally, it didn't take a year for... every single one of those people to change their tune and say, wow, this guy's really smart and he's really good. I have a lot of respect for this guy. So we're not talking about a dumb person. We're not talking about somebody who doesn't have the ability to influence others. And I definitely think he's got his legacy in mind. And to your point, the only way to do that is to actually lick inflation. And... Bring it under control.

Grant Williams

What does this mean perhaps for the other lightning rod on the financial side of the Trump administration, Scott Bessent? Because here's someone who's gone the other way.

Bessent and the good hands

Grant Williams

Scott Bessent has become very much, in my eyes anyway, and others may disagree, but someone who never misses an opportunity to praise President Trump, as he always calls him, very much toes the MAGA line, has been very public in all the stuff he's done. Where does that leave Scott Bessent? And, and. What does that mean? Because obviously, Treasury policy and Treasury action is absolutely going to be very important going forward, given what we've already talked about.

Marvin Barth

Look, that's one of the ones I worry about, because I think you and I have slightly different views. Yeah, yeah, no, we do. Scott Bessent, I've generally been much more impressed with him. And it's not to say that he hasn't made a few errors. But I would also say he's been one of the few people who has been able to walk President Trump. back over the last two years before this week's debacle. And if you lose him, like what's left constraining Trump, right? Like everybody else is abandoning him. We saw within hours, J.D. Vance comes out and effectively sacrifices the president that was his running mate.

Like, I think pretty much everybody else is going to do the same. And whatever you want to say about Scott Bessent, I think his treasury buyback program, which, by the way, he didn't start. It was started under the Biden administration, was a roaring success. And it was doing exactly what it was supposed to do in terms of enhancing liquidity in long-term treasuries. And I would refer anybody who wants just like the best possible defense and explanation of what it is. actually was doing to your interview with Michael Green. He did a great job explaining it. Defense policy, which... Secretary Bessent has been deeply involved in it. He's been doing that across the board. Let me pause there for a second and fill in some background information.

You will remember this because we talked about it after I wrote the piece. I was highlighting after President Trump was reelected in 2024. Look at his cabinet picks. They actually tell you a lot. And while there was a lot of focus on the people like Gaetz and Hegseth and all these, he said, look, these are people that they're supposed to go in and break down the organization because he felt that these institutions were fighting against him last time and he needs somebody to go in and knock heads in the bureaucracy and do them. But if you look, there were two big exceptions, two places that he needed good hands, people who actually would help solidify confidence. in the United States in two areas where it needed. One was the Secretary of State, Marco Rubio. And whatever you think of the Trump administration's policies and Marco Rubio's defense in them, I think it's fair to say that wherever he's gone, he's been a far better spokesperson than anybody else for explaining. I would agree with that.

Grant Williams

Yeah, I would agree with that.

Marvin Barth

And actually, to the extent that people were willing to listen, we're like, okay, we can work with this guy. And the second one was Scott Bessent. And look at, like, I know that a lot of your complaints and other people's complaints have been about the way he's talked to markets and I am the house and things like that. But look at how he's actually acted in G7 and G20 meetings and the feedback on him there. It's all been very positive. And as I said, and he said, one of his key jobs is to be the bond salesman for the United States. Guess what? Liquidity has been. better in treasuries because of him. So across the board, this guy is definitely one of the good hands people. And that's actually one of my biggest concerns is what happens when Rubio and Scott Bessent leave?

Grant Williams

That's a better way for me to frame my question. And I take all your points on board there. I think if we think about treasury secretaries, Tim Geithner was a loud treasury secretary because he had to be given the time that he was in the role. Janet Yellen was a quiet Treasury Secretary. Jack Lew, remember him? Jacob Lew, Jack Lew. All I remember is his signature, which is the most ridiculous signature I've ever seen in my life. And thinking of that on dollar bills, he was silent treasury secretary. Bessent has been very loud. And he's been strapped himself. He's been pugnacious. He's been loud. He's been combative. And he strapped himself to the Trump mast. And I just wonder if that, given what's happened in the midterms, weakens him in any way, shape or form. Maybe it doesn't. But I feel like... If Trump goes down in flames in the elections, Bessent is absolutely, next time he comes out and wants to be loud very publicly, has he done himself more harm than good in terms of the reaction and the buy-in people are going to get? He's going to get from people.

Marvin Barth

That's a really interesting one. And in my piece, I actually listed him as someone you should, you know, I don't think he's on anybody else's list of potential candidates for 2028, but I don't think you should discount him, frankly, because... amazingly, he pulls really well with the MAGA base. They actually like him because he was very pugnacious. So despite the whole Iran war, he doesn't seem to have been sullied by the, oh, he got us into this because he is the treasury secretary, but he has been a very active voice for the MAGA financial immigration and trade policies. And so he has that going for him. I think you're right. The downside for him is that he has been a very clear fighter for the president. And I think you and I discussed over dinner, my read of that is that, like, this is a guy who saw that the way to have influence with the president and one of the reasons why he has been one of the few cabinet members who's been able to any extent at all contain him. is that he's always been seen by the president as fighting for him.

And I think that the MAGA base loved that. The president loved that. Well, now, to exactly your point, he's got to think, well, do I really want to do that? And that's one of the reasons why I worry about him leaving. Because ultimately, if he's not supporting the president, the president still does have the power to get rid of him. One. And two, why have that public... fight with him now. If you have the benefit of the favor of MAGA so far. why get in that fight? Why not step out of the ring for now? So I'm not sure he's going to be tarnished. I don't see signs of it yet. I know that there are a lot of people in markets who feel differently, but markets aren't voters.

The war that lost the election

Grant Williams

Yeah, that's fair enough. Okay, I've left this till essentially last. There's one more thing I want to ask you about after this, but that's going to be a shorter answer to this one. Iran, this idea of foreign wars. Let's talk about that going forward because that's obviously The big takeaway for me, if I've got to go to Trump and tell him what lost this election, it feels like I could just stop with that. I think if it wasn't for Iran, maybe this wouldn't have been anywhere near the outcome. Maybe there are other things, but that feels to me like the big one. What do you think about that? And what do you think happens going forward with that particular situation?

Marvin Barth

I think this is absolutely a different world had he not made the decision to go into Iran. That not only cost him the MAGA voters, but first time Kansas has sent a Democrat to the Senate in 100 years. Why do you think that is? Well, try being a farmer in these markets with diesel prices where they are. Diesel prices wouldn't be where they are without the Iran war. So there is no question the Iran war was a killer here. What's interesting, I was talking with my wife the morning of the election before I was starting to write that postmortem. And we were just talking about how, yeah, these wars just keep killing one president after another.

And so I went back and looked and literally every single war the United States has gotten into since World War II, go back to the Korean War with Harry Truman, it's cost the party in power or the party behind it. In Congress, in the presidency, every single one of them, without exception. And you have to say at this point, like, when are these guys going to listen? From both parties, by the way, it is totally bipartisan. If you look at the list, this is not a Republican or a Democrat issue. But every single time the Americans say, no more foreign wars, stupid. And every single time they still do it. And I'm wondering whether finally this one is just so absolutely clear that this was all about this particular issue. And you do hear, right, like that was the substance of J.D. Vance's, you know, stab in the back tweet. And even the president himself came out immediately after Vance's and said, well, yeah, it probably was the war.

Let's come back to that because one hope, potentially a hopeful sign. but The Democrats, same thing. They said, look, we understood, we heard people say this, no more foreign wars. And so one of the things I think is a great irony here is you will remember when President Trump was elected in 2016 and again in 2024 is one of the great things that all the internationalists worried about is that he was going to bring about a period of American isolationism again. The last... two years have shown, no, quite the opposite. He's been incredibly engaged internationally. Maybe not in the way people like it, but he has been extraordinarily engaged even when you leave out the wars. Well, the irony is that his big screw up with Iran is actually going to cause the rest of America to go into isolation and say, hey, let's stay away from that foreign policy stuff it's only downside for us so I actually think one of the big reads from this is that you will get more isolationism from the United States.

The two rules, revisited

Marvin Barth

There's two big caveats to that. One is that we talked about last time, these two rules I have for how to forecast Donald Trump. What would Jackson do that he represents Jacksonian populism? And two, that he wants to get on Mount Rushmore. And this is about his long-term legacy. Now, This week's result kills the first one in the following sense, in that what would Jackson do was a good predictor of him in part because his instincts seem to be very Jacksonian, but also because the party and base and governing coalition he built around himself was very much people who were in that Jacksonian mold and were. pushing for Jacksonian policies. Well, if all of those people are running for the hills now, he's got none of those constraints on him. And as far as his instincts go. I think his instinct now is going to be 100% self-preservation. So the Jacksonian stuff is out the window now.

And on the getting on Mount Rushmore, that's crazy. I don't think he had a hope to begin with. If he ever did, he certainly doesn't now. But that doesn't mean he thinks so. And so this is a guy who loves to gamble big, and he's got very few options left to him other than foreign policy. And he started this war. And there's a good chance he tries to say, well, I'm going to finish this war. The problem is, given the flip in Congress and the very clear message from them that, hey, no more foreign wars, Jack, he doesn't have much time to get this done. And as I think we've discussed before, and I've written in my research, I do think the Iran war is winnable over years as a blockade. And that requires a whole country effort that is supported by Congress. And it's low cost. It doesn't have to be a bloody affair. But he doesn't have that option anymore. And trying to press it militarily is likely to cause a lot of pain and fail. And I do think in the next two months, we run a significant risk of that. That's why I am hopeful that his admission that this cost them. which maybe means he won't go down that path.

But I do think that's a real risk.

Grant Williams

You've done me the favor of taking my last question because I was going to ask you all about that Rushmore. That was my last question. Look, no, that's perfect. You saved me asking it. But it seems to me he either needs to cut down a cherry tree or abolish slavery again. They're probably his best shots at doing this now. I think that one may have gotten away from him if it was somewhere there in the first place. Listen, Marvin, this has been great. I'm so glad we got to do this because the process is everything. Being able to think about these issues is so important. And there are people out there on Twitter who immediately, and it's so funny, I woke up on Wednesday morning thinking, oh, this is going to be interesting. And of course, out they come swarming around, oh, this blowhard, don't have him on again. I'm like, you're kidding me? I'm going to have him on immediately again, because there's something really important to talk about here. And I'm grateful to you for doing it. I think anyone that subscribes to your excellent research would expect nothing less. And well, certainly the fact that you got this wrong is not going to change the high esteem in which they hold your research. It certainly doesn't do anything to mine. And I think every thoughtful listener of this podcast, and there are a massive majority of them, is going to be grateful to you for coming back on and having this conversation because it's been so valuable to me and I'm sure it will be for most other people too.

Marvin Barth

Well, I hope it is. And I appreciate all your support. And you're absolutely right. the process is the most important part. And that's what I try and focus on is make sure that I learn from my mistakes. And to your earlier point, also hopefully learn from my successes. See, well, what did I get it right for the right reasons and improve my framework and process so I do better in the future.

Grant Williams

Well, listen, I wish you well with all of it. Just remind people where they can follow you because it's going to be more important going forward than it has been in the past I suspect well thank you again

Marvin Barth

for the plug and thank you for the opportunity. It's the best place to look for me is thematicmarkets.com. Everything is there, but you can also find me on Thematic Markets at Substack. And I also have a free Substack called Seriously Marvin. And finally, on the usual social media, both on X and LinkedIn at Thematic Markets.

Grant Williams

Perfect. Marvin, my friend, I've enjoyed this immensely. Thank you for doing it. And we'll have another dinner soon.

Marvin Barth

Thank you very much, sir.

Grant Williams

All right, folks, there you go. I absolutely thoroughly enjoyed that conversation and I got an awful lot out of it. And kudos to Marvin for owning the fact that he got a big call wrong and for coming on, reflecting and talking about it. I think that is way more valuable than people just making bold calls for the sake of it and then slinking away when they don't pan out. So Marvin, my friend, thank you for doing that. For those of you out there listening, I promise you thematicmarkets.substack.com and Marvin's free work. Seriously, Marvin. It's an absolute must sign up thematicmarkets.com. You'll find all his work there and it is excellent. And at Thematic Markets, as he said, on Twitter and on LinkedIn. That's it for me for another podcast. I will be back with another guest in the very near future. In the meantime, once again, thank you all for listening. we discussed should be considered as investment advice. This conversation is for informational and hopefully entertainment purposes only. So while we hope you find it both informative and entertaining, please do your own research or speak to a financial advisor before putting a dime of your money into these crazy markets.